For decades, getting into college meant convincing admissions officers you deserved a spot. Now some universities are doing the convincing: admitting students who haven’t applied, waiving application fees, and enlisting professors to personally recruit prospective freshmen, according to The Hechinger Report in a story also published by NPR.
The shift comes as colleges prepare for a shrinking pool of traditional college-age students while more young people reconsider the four-year path. For the schools that depend on tuition, an empty seat is revenue that never arrives.
An October report from Hanover Research, based on a July survey of 1,000 U.S. high school students ages 16 to 19, found that only 66% were interested in pursuing a bachelor’s degree, down from 79% in 2025. Interest in associate degrees rose from 36% to 45%.
The longer-term trend points the same way. The share of high school graduates going directly to college fell from 70% in 2016 to 63% in 2024, the most recent year available, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
That doesn’t mean enrollment is falling everywhere. Undergraduate enrollment rose 0.6% this fall, according to preliminary National Student Clearinghouse data. But with the number of U.S. high school graduates projected to fall from a record 3.9 million in 2025 to about 3.4 million a year by 2041, according to the Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education, many colleges face growing competition for each incoming class.
Even students who commit don’t always show up
Attracting enough Gen Z applicants is only part of the challenge. Colleges also have to convince the students they admit to actually enroll.
The yield rate, the share of admitted students who ultimately enroll, fell on average from 32% in 2014 to 22% in 2024 at public colleges, according to federal figures cited by The Hechinger Report. Private nonprofit colleges saw a similar decline, from 24% to 18%.
Even an enrollment deposit doesn’t guarantee a student will show up. Known as summer melt, the phenomenon occurs when students commit to a college but don’t enroll in the fall. Some choose another institution, while others don’t attend college at all.
For the college that loses the student, both outcomes mean lost tuition revenue. Only the second means the student has left higher education altogether.
At Whittier College near Los Angeles, the melt rate reached 17% this year, meaning roughly one in six students who committed ultimately didn’t show up, The Wall Street Journal reported.
More students are also hedging their bets. In a Human Capital Education survey of more than 72,000 admitted students at 91 institutions, 10% placed deposits at more than one college in 2026, twice the share in 2024.
Cost and doubts about value keep admitted students away
A January brief published by the National College Attainment Network identified unexpected costs, unresolved financial aid, and emotional barriers such as fear of leaving home, uncertainty, and doubts about whether college is right for them as factors contributing to summer melt.
Those concerns overlap with the ones that discourage students from pursuing college in the first place. Two questions loom over both decisions: whether a student can afford college, and whether the education will be worth it.
In the Human Capital survey, 60% of respondents listed affordability, financial aid and net price among their five most important factors when choosing a college. Nearly three in 10 waited until they received financial aid offers before deciding where to enroll.
Those worries don’t necessarily disappear after admission. Liz Colavita, director of survey research at Human Capital Education, pointed to the firm’s finding that 21% of admitted students said their families were insufficiently prepared to pay for college. An acceptance letter or deposit, she told Fortune, doesn’t resolve those financial obstacles.
For some, the cost keeps them out entirely. Six percent of admitted students surveyed in 2026 said they would not attend any college that fall, up from 3% in 2025. Among those students, 51% cited an inability to afford college.
Students are also reconsidering which skills will pay off in a changing job market. In Hanover’s survey, 25% said recent developments in AI have made them more interested in developing human-centered skills, and Fortune has reported on Gen Z’s growing turn toward skilled trades.
“Students aren’t necessarily questioning whether education has value. They’re asking what kind of education will be valuable to them,” Colavita said. “Students want to see how their education connects to the world they’ll enter after graduation.”
How colleges are trying to stop the melt
Some colleges are reaching students before they apply. More than 820,000 students received proactive admission offers during the 2025–26 season through Common App’s direct admissions program. The number of participating institutions has nearly doubled, from 119 in 2024–25 to 234 in 2026–27.
Making admission easier can remove some initial barriers, said Ken Anselment, senior director of enrollment strategy at Human Capital Education. But it doesn’t necessarily address concerns about affordability, whether students feel they belong, or the steps they still need to complete before arriving on campus.
Georgia State University went after that last stretch. A $125,000 digital campaign targeted admitted students and their parents on platforms including Facebook, Instagram and YouTube. The messages first highlighted the university’s academic strengths and graduates’ career prospects, then shifted to reminders about enrollment requirements such as orientation registration.
The university credits the campaign, which earned a CASE Circle of Excellence award, with reducing summer melt from 22% to 8%. It also attributes $3.2 million in tuition revenue to the effort.
“One of the most important things colleges can do is treat the enrollment deposit not as the finish line, but as a milestone marking the beginning of another critical stage in the student’s journey,” Anselment said.
He said preventing summer melt requires coordination among admissions, financial aid, student accounts, housing and advising. Colleges should monitor whether students are completing important enrollment steps and reach out when they hit obstacles, rather than discovering the problem after a student fails to show up.
Discounts climb as budgets tighten
Reminders and easier admissions can only go so far when students can’t afford to attend. Many colleges are leaning on financial aid instead.
Private nonprofit colleges discounted an average of 57.1% of published tuition and fees for first-time, full-time undergraduates in 2025–26, up from 54.5% in 2024–25, according to preliminary estimates from a National Association of College and University Business Officers study of 258 institutions. The average discount rate for all undergraduates reached 51.3%, topping the previous peak of 50.8% in 2022–23.
Some schools are going further. Whitman College in Washington state will cap tuition at 10% of parental income for students who enroll beginning in fall 2027.
The aid shows up on the balance sheet. At DePaul University, rising student financial need pushed institutional aid up by nearly $15.5 million, to roughly $372 million for fiscal 2027, administrators said in October. Higher aid was one of several pressures on the university’s budget.
DePaul said declining enrollment among continuing undergraduates, rather than new students, was its most significant enrollment challenge. It also said it could not afford salary increases this year.
But more recruitment spending and financial aid aren’t always the answer, Anselment said. Colleges also need to consider what they’re offering, which students they’re trying to reach, and whether the price makes sense to those students.
The financial consequences of missing an enrollment target also depend on scale, he said. Losing 100 freshmen would hit a college expecting 400 students very differently than one expecting 2,000. Schools must also weigh how much net tuition revenue those students would have generated against what it would have cost to educate them.
“The point of diminishing returns comes when an institution spends more to enroll students without generating sufficient additional revenue,” he said.
This story was originally featured on Fortune.com








